Aisle Digital · Platform comparison
The Shopify Plus alternative you actually own.
Magento Open Source, built and run by our ecommerce team for UK mid-size brands and B2B catalogues. No licence, no revenue share, no lock-in. And a straight answer on when Shopify Plus is still the better choice.
The short answer
Shopify Plus or Magento Open Source?
Magento Open Source is the main licence-free alternative to Shopify Plus. Shopify Plus starts at $2,300–$2,500 a month, can move to an unpublished revenue-based fee, and adds 0.2% on third-party payment gateways. Magento Open Source has no licence fee, but you pay for hosting, security patches and periodic upgrades. It usually suits larger catalogues, B2B and complex integrations best.
Side by side
Shopify Plus vs Magento 2: how they compare.
| Factor | Shopify Plus | Magento Open Source (built by Aisle) |
|---|---|---|
| Licence or platform fee | From $2,500/month on a 1-year term, or $2,300/month on a 3-year term | £0. Open source licence, no subscription |
| Revenue and transaction fees | Higher-volume merchants can be moved to a variable platform fee based on revenue; Shopify does not publish the rate, threshold or cap | None. The platform takes no share of your sales |
| Payment gateway freedom | Shopify Payments carries no extra platform fee; third-party gateways add 0.2% per transaction | Any gateway (Stripe, Adyen, Worldpay, PayPal and more) with no platform surcharge |
| Hosting | Included and fully managed by Shopify | Not included. Managed hosting on AWS London, sized to your traffic, paid monthly |
| B2B features | Native B2B: company accounts, customer-specific pricing, payment terms, quantity rules | Customer groups and tier pricing built in. Company accounts, quotes and requisition lists need paid extensions or custom work (Adobe’s B2B module is Adobe Commerce only) |
| Catalogue scale and variants | Handles large catalogues well; up to 2,048 variants per product | No platform cap on products or attributes; complex configurable products and attribute sets. Performance depends on hosting and build quality |
| Checkout customisation | Customised through Shopify’s checkout extensibility framework, within the limits Shopify sets | Full code-level control of checkout, or a paid checkout module such as Hyvä Checkout |
| Ownership and lock-in | You own your data, theme and domain; the platform and its terms are Shopify’s | You own the code, the server and the data. Move agency or host whenever you like |
| Upgrades and maintenance | Shopify handles platform updates and security | Your responsibility: security patches, and a version upgrade roughly every 2 years to stay supported. We do this for you on a care plan |
| Typical build cost | Usually lower upfront; themes and apps cover a lot | Usually higher upfront for custom work. Fixed quote after a call and audit |
Three-year cost
What you actually pay.
Licence fees are only part of the bill, so here is a like-for-like view of the costs that differ most between the two platforms over three years. Figures are illustrative, not a quote.
| Cost item (3 years) | Shopify Plus | Magento Open Source |
|---|---|---|
| Platform licence | $82,800 on a 3-year term (about £62,000); $90,000 on a 1-year term (about £68,000) | £0 |
| Variable platform fee | Possible at this revenue level; rate not published, so not included | £0 |
| Third-party gateway surcharge (0.2%) | £12,000 if you use a third-party gateway; £0 on Shopify Payments | £0 |
| Hosting, patching and care | Hosting included | £5,400–£18,000 (£150–£500/month on our published hosting and care range) |
| Version upgrade | Included | At least one upgrade likely in 3 years; quoted against your extensions and custom code |
| Apps or extensions | Monthly app subscriptions; varies widely by stack | Mostly one-off extension licences plus annual support renewals; varies by stack |
| Build | Quoted per project | Quoted per project; usually higher upfront |
Illustrative only. Assumes a UK brand turning over £2m a year online (£6m over three years), US dollar prices converted at $1.33 to £1, excluding VAT, card processing fees (which apply on both platforms), apps, extensions and build. Shopify’s variable platform fee is negotiated and unpublished, so it is excluded and could raise the Shopify figure. Magento hosting and care uses our published range and will be quoted on your traffic and catalogue. Your real numbers depend on your setup; we’ll model both platforms for you after the audit.
When Shopify Plus is the better choice
- Your team is small and you don’t want to own servers, patches or upgrades. Shopify runs the platform for you.
- Speed to market matters more than control, and a theme plus apps covers what you need.
- You’re happy with Shopify Payments, so the third-party gateway surcharge doesn’t apply.
- You need native B2B on a hosted platform and don’t want to fund extensions or custom development.
When Magento Open Source wins
- Large or complex catalogues: many attributes, configurable products, multiple stores, languages or currencies.
- B2B selling with trade pricing, quoting and account logins, especially alongside an ERP or PIM.
- Growing revenue where a licence or revenue-based platform fee becomes a significant line in your costs.
- You want full control of checkout, data and hosting, with no platform rules and the freedom to change supplier.
Honest costs
What Magento costs you that Shopify doesn’t.
- Hosting: Magento needs properly sized servers with search, caching and backups. It is a monthly bill Shopify customers don’t see.
- Security patches: Adobe releases them regularly and they need applying and testing promptly. That is skilled labour, every quarter.
- Version upgrades: each Magento release is supported for a fixed period, so plan an upgrade roughly every 2 years. 2.4.6 lost support on 11 August 2026; 2.4.8 is supported until April 2028. There is no paid extended support for Open Source.
- Extensions: B2B features, some payment and shipping integrations, and Hyvä Checkout carry licence fees. The Hyvä Theme itself has been free and open source since November 2025.
- Development: changes are custom code, not app installs, so budget for ongoing development time.
FAQ
Platform questions, answered.
Is Magento Open Source really free?
The software is. It is released under an open source licence with no subscription or revenue share. You still pay for hosting, any paid extensions, the build, and the patching and upgrades that keep it secure. We itemise every one of those in your quote.
What’s the difference between Magento Open Source and Adobe Commerce?
Adobe Commerce is the paid edition, licensed annually and priced on your revenue. It adds native B2B features, extra merchandising tools and Adobe support. Magento Open Source is the free core platform. Most mid-size UK brands can get what they need from Open Source plus a small set of extensions.
Is Magento more expensive to run than Shopify Plus?
It can be, depending on your size. Magento has no licence fee but you pay for hosting, maintenance and upgrades. Shopify Plus includes hosting but charges a monthly fee and, for higher-volume merchants, a revenue-based fee. We model both on your numbers so you can see which is cheaper over three years.
How often does Magento need upgrading?
Each release gets security support for a fixed period, so most stores upgrade roughly every two years. Magento 2.4.6 lost support in August 2026 and 2.4.8 is supported until April 2028. If you’re on 2.4.6 or older, we’ll check your version and quote the upgrade.
Can you migrate us from Shopify to Magento?
Yes. We move products, customers, order history and URLs, set up redirects to protect your search rankings, and run both sites side by side until the new one is signed off. If the audit shows Shopify Plus suits you better, we’ll tell you that instead.